Skip to content Skip to navigation

What If California Had Won the 1963 Case Over the Division of the Colorado River?

Dec 21 2016

Outside of Phoenix, Arizona.    Daniel Piraino via Flickr

By Felicity Barringer

This is the first of a series of occasional posts looking at at how the West would have changed if a major historical event had — or had not — occurred. Scholars are often wary of such counterfactual explorations, but, carefully framed, they can help our understanding of today’s disputes. Here, we look at the implications of a different Supreme Court decision in the 1963 Arizona v. California case.

When the Court took the case in 1961, it was thought that a ruling could resolve nearly 50 years of bitter water wars. Arizona’s government long believed California was stealing a march on them and stealing their water in the process. This sense of being bilked had for 20 years prompted Arizona’s refusal to sign that the 1922 Colorado River Compact. In 1952, Arizona went to the Court, saying its ability to use Colorado River water was hampered by California’s excessive claims.

Such cases are often turned over to a special master; so was this. In 1962, reviewing the master’s report, eight Justices found themselves split, four to four. (Earl Warren, a former governor of California, recused himself.) Four felt that deference to the doctrine of prior appropriation called for a ruling in favor of California, with the older claims. Four were swayed by Arizona’s equity arguments.

As described in a 2013 Arizona Law Review article, Justice Felix Frankfurter, before a stroke forced him to retire, wrote a long memo on the case favoring most of California’s claims. Had it convinced just one colleague, the memo could have been the deciding opinion. We asked economists and water lawyers to speculate how Arizona might have evolved if California had prevailed 53 years ago.

There are two big questions:

  • Would Arizona have been guaranteed 2.8 million acre-feet of Colorado River water annually?
     
  • Would it have been able to get more than $4 billion to build the Central Arizona Project and bring the water to its population centers?

Arizona’s victory allowed it to create the Central Arizona Project, which pumps about 1.5 million acre-feet of water uphill from Lake Havasu to a point just south of Tuscon, as described in this 2002 paper by Michael Hanemann of the University of California, Berkeley. Three counties along the way have tripled or quadrupled their populations since 1970.

Bringing the Colorado River to the Heart of Arizona

Finished in 1993, The Central Arizona Project is the largest canal in the United States. The aqueduct brings Colorado River water to farms, cities, and industry in Arizona, and has contributed to the rapid growth of metropolitan Phoenix and Tucson.

Sources: Central Arizona Project, Arizona State University, University of Arizona, Natural Earth Data (basemap), California Department of Water Resources (California aqueducts)

Geoff McGhee/Bill Lane Center for the American West, Stanford University

This was a dream of Arizona’s 20th-century leaders. From the 1920s on, they fought to get a secure supply of Colorado River water to the center of the state. Backpedaling to Arizona’s dreams of the 1950s, we find a time when the seven states of the Colorado River basin had agreed to divide the river’s bounty with half of what was supposed to be 15 million acre-feet annually going to the Upper Basin, and half going to the Lower Basin states of California, Nevada and Arizona.

In 1928, the Boulder Canyon Project Act authorized construction of what is now Hoover Dam. It also authorized the lower basin’s share to be divided between the states with California getting 4.4 million acre feet — about 1 million less than it had been taking — while Nevada got 300,000 and Arizona 2.8 million. But the states themselves did not agree to that apportionment. Without the Supreme Court decision, which confirmed 1928 law’s water division, would Arizona have had a guaranteed water supply?

“I tend to doubt it,” said Rita Maguire, who for a decade was director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources and is now a partner at Maguire, Pearce & Storey in Phoenix. For decades, she said, Arizona had been in unequal combat with California in Congress; its path to guaranteed water was blocked “not only [by] the power of the California congressional delegation but the power of California farmers.”

How the Colorado River is Allocated Today

The seven states of the Colorado River basin share what was expected to be 15 million acre-feet of water annually – though the total has turned out to be considerably less in many years.

Bill Lane Center for the American West, Stanford University

Without a guarantee of 2.8 million acre-feet of Colorado River water, would the Central Arizona Project, known as CAP, have been built? Barton “Buzz” Thompson, a Stanford law professor, believes it probably would not have been constructed in its current form. “It could have made it impossible for Arizona to convince banks or politicians that they had enough water to provide a secure water project,” he said. Demonstrating there was a reliable supply of water to sell, and thus make money to repay the cost of the project, was critical. But, he speculated, Arizona could have built a smaller project, carrying less water, to the state’s population centers.

“Arizona trades on people,” said Timothy James, an economist at Arizona State University. Without CAP, “it definitely would have been difficult for developers to build more housing and would have constrained the number of people who moved here.”

Less water, less development. As Timothy James, an economist at Arizona State University said, “Arizona trades on people.” Without CAP, he said, “it definitely would have been difficult for developers to build more housing and would have constrained the number of people who moved here.” In reality, as described in his 2014 paper, CAP’s impact was transformative. From 1970 to 2015, Maricopa County, which includes Phoenix and Scottsdale, grew from 982,000 people to more than 4 million.

Did the 1963 ruling help or hurt the environment? Imposing the environmental ethos of the 21st century on the mid 20th century is risky. As Dr. James said, “Humans are incredibly ingenious — without CAP, that would have meant maybe we would have started to be much more careful about our uses of water 40 years ago.” And had California gotten more water then, it might have been profligate with it. But if California had more access to the Colorado River now, it would be easier to restore the dewatered Colorado River delta in Mexico or replenish the depleted Salton Sea, which is slowly disappearing.

And had Arizona failed to get a guarantee of Colorado River water, its farmers might have continued the unsustainable pumping of groundwater; in 1980, under duress from President Jimmy Carter (who had threatened to cut funding for CAP), Arizona passed a strict groundwater management bill. That bill, and the cost of CAP water, prompted many farmers to sell agricultural land, fueling the swift suburban development.

Ag's Declining Share of Central Arizona Project Bounty

The high cost of CAP water, relative to groundwater, is thought to have helped prompt Arizona farmers to sell agricultural land for suburban development. Over time, the share of CAP water devoted to agriculture has declined in favor of other uses.

Sources: Central Arizona Project, Arizona State University

Geoff McGhee/Bill Lane Center for the American West, Stanford University

“The one devastating environmental consequence [of the Court decision] is the loss of water to the Colorado River delta,” said Mark Squillace, a specialist in natural resources law at the University of Colorado Law School.

As Mark Squillace, a specialist in natural resources law at the University of Colorado Law School, said, “The one devastating environmental consequence [of the Court decision] is the loss of water to the Colorado River delta.” And, he pointed out, the coal-fired Navajo Generating Station in northern Arizona, built primarily to run the pumps pushing CAP water uphill, remains a source of significant air pollution.

Obviously, counterfactual speculation can soon run down a rabbit hole. But the views of these specialists make it plain that, had Justice Frankfurter written a more convincing memo in 1962 and found one more vote, Arizona would be a different state today.

 

 

Read Next in ...& the West

In the Pacific Northwest, Native Fishing Rights Take on a Role as Environmental Protector

The fishing rights promised to the Pacific Northwest’s Native Americans 160 years ago are proving the sharpest knife the region's environmentalists possess. So far in 2016, these rights have undergirded decisions to block two planned terminals to ship coal to Asia. Another decision could cost Washington state a billion dollars in highway repairs aimed at protecting salmon.

 

Submit a Comment

We'd like to know what you think. We will not share your email address or add you to any lists. If you'd like to be notified about new blog posts and news from the Center, you can join our mailing list.

You will receive emails no more than once a week. We will not share your information.

 

...& the Best

Western Articles and Media Elsewhere
Compiled by Felicity Barringer, Devon Burger, Madison Pobis, and Sierra Garcia

Articles Worth Reading: February 18, 2020

Oil Drilling, Coal Mining and Grazing Can Begin Where They Were Barred in an area that was, until recently, within the bounds of Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears National Monuments. If fossil-fuel companies decide it could pay, coal mining or oil and gas development could now happen on more than 1,000 square miles within the former boundaries of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. Tribal and advocacy groups requested measures to protect cultural sites in the Bears Ears area, but the new plan includes none of them. In fact, tribal spokesmen say the new plan removes protections that pre-dated the official designation of Bears Ears as a National Monument in 2016. Boise State Public Radio

After Three Texas Coal Plants Closed, Air Pollution Fell Dramatically, with emissions dropping by 152,000 tons in the first year. This included an 11 percent reduction of fine particulate matter that can cause asthma. This is an important step, but environmental advocates are still pushing Texas to monitor unauthorized air pollution. Though legal air pollution is declining, other emissions are increasing and are expected to worsen in the future. Texas Observer

Water Bottling Companies Have Rights to Water from a Small-Town Spring, but Washington State is looking to change that. When the tap into spring-fed sources, companies deplete springs and aquifers in order to ship water elsewhere and make a profit. This follows similar local efforts in Oregon and Montana — though a Montana county’s ordinance has been challenged in court. Washington is working to protect its local water supply as water scarcity becomes a more pressing issue. The Counter Pew Trusts Stateline

Printed Batteries Are Now Available, with Imprint Energy, a Bay Area company, printing hundreds of thousands of batteries that hold more energy and they claim are safer than lithium-ion products. They may help us tackle a number of environmental questions in a more efficient and safer way. Christine Ho, the company's co-founder and CEO, discusses the possibilities in this podcast. Green Tech Media

The Death of Even One Mountain Lion is a Significant Loss. Los Angeles is one of just two major cities that has big cats living within city limits. In the Santa Monica mountains, it is clear how difficult coexistence can be. Under certain conditions, property owners may take lethal action to protect their pets and livestock; the property owner responsible for killing a mountain lion called P-56 had lost 12 animals in nine separate invidents. Yet the loss of the mountain lion can have serious ramification on the species that already lacks genetic diversity. Outside Online

Articles Worth Reading: February 4, 2020

California Adopts Mandatory Composting Regulations to cut organized waste disposal by 75 percent over the next five years. Recycling rates have dropped since China stopped accepting much recycling; California’s recycling rate is down to 40 percent. Among other things, the rule aims to recover one-fifth of the edible food that is now thrown away. California is the first state to require groups that generate food waste – like grocery stores and restaurants -- to donate some unused food to people in need. Waste 360

By Allowing an Oil Company’s Operations to Harm Beluga Whales, the federal government is shirking its responsibility under the Endangered Species Act, according to lawsuits filed by two environmental groups on behalf of beluga whales in Alaska’s Cook Inlet. The seismic blasts used by companies exploring to discover oil deposits, the nonprofit groups claim, can cause hearing loss in the whales, disrupt their communications, and hurt their ability to catch fish. Associated Press

Rainfall Causes Exponentially Larger Floods than Snowmelt, new research indicates. A study of 36 years’ worth of data shows rainfall-driven flooding can be 2.5 times more extensive than floods generated by snowmelt. This means that the western U.S. might face new challenges as the atmosphere continues to warm and more precipitation falls as rain. Stanford Earth

Starting With Four Northern California Communities, PG&E is Working to Build Microgrids that can resist fire-related power outages. These small power networks are usually plugged into the main electrical grid, but at times of fire-related shutoffs, they can be disconnected, creating independent islands of power. They will keep lights burning in areas that are especially vulnerable to outages, but microgrids also raise concerns about carbon impacts, as long as the grids continue to be powered with diesel. Utility Dive

Microsoft Pledged to Become “Carbon Negative,” meaning the company will remove more carbon than it emits by 2030—but the Xbox gaming console might stand in its way. The device uses a disproportionate amount of electricity, but its emissions also depend on individual behavior. A 2019 study by Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory found that annual emissions from Americans playing video games equal those of 85 million refrigerators or five million cars. Grist

Articles Worth Reading: January 21, 2020

Glacier National Park is Going… Going… Not Quite Gone. While the park has lost more than three-quarters of the glaciers that defined its landscape 75 years ago, it still has at least 26, contrary to predictions that by 2020 warming would cost the park all its namesake ice. So park officials have been removing the official signs warning that all glaciers would melt by 2020, and a scientist is explaining why some predictions are iffy. Montana Public Radio

The Navajo Nation and Salt River Project Are Working Together to Develop a Solar Energy project. This 200-megawatt project is an important step in the Navajo Nation’s effort to move away from coal, which was an economic lifeline until the closing of the Navajo Generating Plant late last year. Associated Press/Durango Herald Native News Online

When Smoke’s in the Air, Death Rates Inch Up, finds a new study by University of Washington researchers and Washington state health officials. Researchers correlated a dozen years of deaths starting in 2006 and matched them with wildfire smoke’s locations, finding a one-percent increase in non-traumatic mortality on smoky days. “Estimates of death represent the tip of the iceberg,” said one researcher, pointing other, less-dramatic health consequences. Crosscut

Scientists Think They Know How a Million Seabirds Died: a 700-day marine heat wave in the northeast Pacific. Between 2014 and 2016, the heat wave led to above-average surface water temperatures, killing many small fish that the seabirds, known as common murres —as well as other species in the Gulf of Alaska—rely on. Associated Press KQED PLOS

Three Men, a Boy, and Four Goats — Traveling Together On A 100-Mile Trail. Bruce Kirkby recounts his experience and shares striking images of a father-son adventure in Utah. Maptia

Puget Sound Tribes and Scientists Join Forces to Breed Millions of Clams When members of the Suquamish tribe noticed a decrease in local cockle populations, Elizabeth Unsell, the tribal shellfish biologist, approached the Puget Sound Restoration Fund (PSRF) about possible options. Now, the tribe, PSRF, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration have strategies to enhance shellfish breeding; this year, they succeeded in breeding more than a million juveniles The New Food Economy

Articles Worth Reading: January 6, 2020

Two Arizona Leaders Clashed Repeatedly Over Who Could Use How Much Colorado River Water. But when Tom Buschatzke, director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources, and Ted Cooke, general manager of the Central Arizona Project, realized their impasse could hurt all the water users they represented, they found a way to agree. So the fractious forces within Arizona united to join California and Nevada to approve the Lower Basin Drought Contingency Plan governing the future of the Colorado River. A year-end editorial called it “nothing short of historic….it proves that people with wildly different viewpoints can learn to work together and accomplish things that matter.” Arizona Republic

Successful Conservation Means More Seafloor Opening to Trawlers, some 15 years after extensive closures decimated the fishing industry that scrapes the ocean floor for fish like rockfish, perch and sole. Overfishing and crude methods led environmentalists to seek protection for the fish and the coral reefs. They successfully pushed for large closures, but have made peace with many fishermen as they now work to revive the industry in a sustainable fashion. The new task: revive consumer interest in species that have long been off the shelves. Fortune

Tumbling Into the New Year, Drivers in Washington Found Themselves Trapped by a growing forest of tumbleweeds. Thousands of the plants, which grow copiously in a valley near state route 240, were dislodged by high winds on New Year’s Eve, then clustered in an area of the highway that quickly became impassable. At least 20 people were trapped in cars under the growing pile of plants. One state trooper called it a “tumbleweed avalanche;” indeed, the plants, which had piled up to heights of 20 feet or more, were eventually removed by a snowplow. Spokane Statesman-Review Atlas Obscura

New Mexico’s Wind-Blown, Shape-Shifting Gypsum Dune Field Became the Country’s 62nd National Park in late December, and is now known as White Sands National Park. This is a traditional outcome for most national monuments, and it happened a little over a year after two national monuments in Utah were cut down or cut apart. But after 86 years as a national monument, the 275-square-mile stretch &mdash which grew slightly thanks to a land exchange with the national missile range nearby — has full park status. The area, with more than 800 animal species, has been described as a desert Galapagos. REI Blog

Diagnosis: Desertification. Prescription: Bison. In northern New Mexico’s state of Chihuahua, where decades of cattle-grazing have left dry fields that strong local winds turn into dust clouds, a local rancher is raising a herd of bison, whose grazing habits are conducive to restoring land dessicated by cattle. The ranch, called El Uno, is hoping to help restore both the bison — nearly wiped out from Canada to Chihuahua by Western settlers in the 19th and 20th centuries — and the land itself. Living On Earth Podcast

Articles Worth Reading: December 16, 2019

Alaska’s Cod Fishery Shuts Down for 2020 Season Due to Climate Stress. The marine heat wave of 2014 slashed fish stocks in half with steady declines predicted for the future. Dwindling cod populations aren’t only bad for marine species like steller sea lions, but also for the local fishermen who have historically relied on the fishery for much of their income. “I'd like to think that I could fish cod one more time before I retire, but I don't know. I simply don't know where we're going here,” says Frank Miles, a pot cod fisherman based in Kodiak. NPR

The Ruling on Lawsuit Upholds Rights for Klamath, Yurok, and Hoopa Valley Tribes in a case where irrigation water was redirected for threatened and endangered species in the Klamath River. High Country News

Unbridled Groundwater Pumping Could Dry Up Arizona’s San Pedro River as more and more wells are drilled to support a growing population. More than 350 animal species and 600 plant species rely on the ecosystems supported by the river, and some are hurtling toward extinction. Even if all pumping stopped today, the basin would likely still see reduced outputs after years of extraction and hydrologic change. Arizona Republic

Increasing the Water Taken From the Delta May Not Hurt the Delta Smelt because the tiny fish is already too far gone, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife found. Two scientific experts on the California fish dissect this opinion, and argue that the government’s habitat restoration plans may be too diffuse to do much good. “Current smelt populations are too small to be able to see an immediate … response to habitat changes alone,” they found. California Water Blog, PPIC

Studying Urban Coyotes Resonates With the Lived Experience of Social Inequity for Christopher Schell, a researcher at the University of Washington’s Tacoma campus.“Coyotes are big enough to be the apex predator in cities, but still small enough to navigate those cities,” says Schell. He discovered pups learn not to fear humans by watching their parents. “Each generation is bolder than the last,” he says. But city-dwellers do fear coyotes. “They’re hated on. They’re feared. People try to eradicate them from an environment. They learn quickly and figure out ways to survive in cities.” Recognizing racial and social inequity in the urban landscape, he says,may provide a fresh perspective on what science often overlooks. University of Washington Magazine

Articles Worth Reading: December 2, 2019

A Downward Trend for California’s Colorado River Water Consumption is shown by the most recent datasets. A favorable snowpack melt in the Sierras reduced the stress on Southern California water needs from the Colorado River. “Simply put, we are consistently using less water,” in spite of population growth, says Eric Kuhn, a retired general manager for the Colorado River Water Conservation District. John Fleck/Inkstain

Idaho Fisheries Managers Predict Long-term Success for Sockeye Salmon despite a small percentage of recruits making it back to Snake River. Unusually high water temperatures and harsh transitions from soft to hard water led to low success in the past few years. New adjustments to the program and favorable conditions could mean much higher returns of salmon to the Sawtooth Basin in 2020 and 2021. Associated Press/Idaho Falls Post Register

The First Recording of a Blue Whale Heartbeat Suggests an Upper Limit for Animal Size. Researchers at Stanford University recovered the data from a monitor that the team attached to a blue whale with suction cups while it was surfacing between dives near Monterey, California. During dives up to 200 meters, the 220-ton whale’s heart rate can slow to as few as two beats per minute in order to conserve oxygen. Even after surfacing, their hearts likely can’t beat faster than 37 beats per minute, and this ability to bounce between such extremes is what helps such a massive animal dive so deep for food. If a deep-diving animal were any bigger, it’s likely the heart couldn’t beat fast enough to compensate for the oxygen lost during dives. The Atlantic

Lighthouse Relocation Stirs Up Tensions in a Coastal California Town. Eroding cliffs surrounding the original landmark prompted the community to move the local Trinidad Memorial Lighthouse. Some locals want to preserve the names of those buried or lost at sea, but native tribes are worried that a new location would disturb ancestral burial grounds and reinforce painful histories. Los Angeles Times

A Man Unearths His Ancestral History of the Crow Tribe in Yellowstone Valley by inviting tribal members to share stories and spending time in Montana’s Absaroka-Beartooth mountains. An archaeological excavation revealed the original foundations of a fort that had remained intact for more than 130 years. A new school curriculum centered on the fort and the history of the land has sparked new energy to honor the Apsalooke people and their traditions. Mountain Journal

Graphics & the West

Where California Grows Its Food

See the most detailed survey ever done of crops and land use in California. It covers nine million acres of land devoted to grapes, alfalfa, cotton, plums, you name it – food for people and animals all over the world. View map »

California's Changing Energy Mix

A look at the energy sources California utilities have used gives us insights into the state’s progress in decarbonizing its electricity supply. In 2015, 35% of total electricity generation (in-state generation plus imported electricity) came from zero-greenhouse-gas sources, which include solar, wind, hydropower, and nuclear. View Graphic »

U.S. Conservation Easements

Conservation easements of various kinds cover more than 22 million acres of land in the United States, according to the National Conservation Easement Database, a public-private partnership. Take a look at our interactive map of nearly every conservation easement, with details on over 130,000 sites. View map »

 

Recent Center News

Feb 18 2020 | ... & the West Blog, ... & the Best | Stories Recommended by the ‘... & the West’ Blog
Opening once-protected national monument land to coal mining; closing Texas coal plants means cleaner air; Washington state looks to limit water bottling companies’ access to spring-fed water; the potential of printed batteries; and more environmental news from around the West.
Feb 7 2020 | Nora Hennessy Spotlight | Center News, Happenings, Topics of the West
Internship co-sponsored by the Bill Lane Center tasks Stanford graduate student with evaluating Palo Alto's energy storage programs
Feb 4 2020 | Center News, Happenings
Calling all journalists: Apply for a Bill Lane Center media fellowship beginning February 17, 2020.